Monday, October 17, 2005

So this morning during my holy hour I was reading Evangelium Vitae and came across this fist-pumping statement by our beloved JP2:


"Given such a grave situation, we need now more than ever to have the courage to look the truth in the eye and to call things by their proper name, without yielding to compromises or to the temptation of self-deception. In this regard the Prophet is extremely straightforward: "Woe to those who call evil good and good evil, who put darkness for light and light for darkness" (Is 5:20)."

Now, this has never really been something I've had a problem with. I am the same girl who, when offended by Jesus Christ Superstar this summer yelled "Heretics!" and walked out. So, naturally, the idea of "calling things by their proper name" is quite attractive to me.

As such, I have decided to create the t-shirt below. It was inspired by class today, where we discussed a heretical viewpoint of the Catholic Church's moral teaching on sex. It was presented as "another" way to look at the information presented in Humane Vitae, and, as such, should be discussed for its value. Now, I see the purpose of discussing heresy - I do not think we should turn a blind eye to it - however, in such cases when the heresy is presented as having a morsel of truth, well, I have a problem with that.

My favorite argument from the piece we studied was that "sterilization is acceptable, as it is natural for the body to become sterile with age." Ah yes. Just help the inevitable along. How noble of you. While you're at it, I fear that it is inevitable that I will die. So, please kill me. Or maybe I'll just take the liberty to do it myself. It is, after all, inevitable, yes? Or, if you think me obscenely disproportionate, take this example. It is inevitable that, given your family history, you will go bald. Shave your head. Or go blind. Gouge out your eyes. Or deaf. Damage your inner ear. Or maybe it is inevitable that one day you will be hit by a car (yes, you have the gift of prophecy). So why not just run in front of one? It is, after all, only natural to act upon the inevitable.

It is a weak weak weak argument. With weak weak weak logic.

And, when I called it out, the professor said, "Now, Angela. Maybe you should have a little more respect for her points." To which I shook my head and turned away. She responded "...or not. That's fine too."

You're darn right it's fine! It's more than fine! It's only correct! What respect am I to muster for heresy? Am I to humble myself before Arius? Or Luther? Or Calvin? I think not.

Anyway, I quieted down, and class resumed as usual (with little to no participation/learning involved), and she made the point that sex is "a biological function", there is no point in fudging with the sexual act, just as those who have lost their teeth fudge with false teeth, or those who have lost their hearing fudge with hearing aids.

I kid you not. That was her point.

Rusty attacked that one, saying that it is ridiculous to degrade the act of sex into a matter of false teeth and hearing aids. It was met with disagreement, saying that "sex really is biological, just as the act of birthing a chid is."

I uttered a comment to myself which will not be repeated, and put my head down on my desk.

And hence: the t-shirts. I say we get one for every member of the class. Hell, why not get one for everyone in the school?

Blimey.


Comments:
One simple suggestion. Jesus didn't treat those who disagreed with Him with disrespect or contempt. It is only through imitation of Christ that you will change minds and hearts, not by shouting and raging.

HAve you considered transferring to Dominican University in River Forest, Illinois? It is an incredible school and the nuns, Sinsenawa Dominicans, are incredible people. It is a happy, loving place. Just a thought.

Peace.
 
I have not considered it.

Nor will I.
 
No transfering my dear...we are here to fight for truth and transform the world. You rock my world and with the grace of Christ we are making this happen!
 
And, just for fun...go ahead and count how many times Jesus uses the words "You hypocrites."

I am not disrespectful nor am I contemptuous. I just call it like I see it. And the annoyance you see here on my blog is not reflective of how I really am with people - I am charitable with them. Truth must be told with love.

This blog simply reflects my frustrations.
 
Hey Angela! You are made of tougher stuff than I. Which is why I chose to attend school among the pagans, rather than at any of the "Catholic" Universities in DC. Much better for the blood preassure you know? ;)

You keep on trucking girl. You let them betrayers of Ex Corde Ecclesia have it.
 
Ugh...I know what you mean. I go to a Catholic (girls) high school (quite different, I know.) and having pro life views is utterly looked down on. I'm taking away our "freedom" by speaking out against contraception. LOL, what freedom? The freedom for men, more like! Yay for you though...
L&ps in JMJ+
 
Stupid professors can do stupid things. I went to Steubie for undergrad, so I didn't enoucnter that, but being at an uber liberal public school was totally different. I was in a class called, "Cahtolicism, Existentialism and Marxism." I had to read so much that semester to actually be able to correct the prof when he misrepresented the Church, and it was kind of fruitless because he would give me B's on everything. He would say that the presentation of my argument was good and my ideas were interesting, but they were "wrong" because "everybody knows there's no such thing as grace." That was news to me!

Another one of my friends took her PhD comps this spring and wrote a really good essay that mentioned the idea of truth and reality in a Catholic context. One of her readers passed it with honors and said it should be published. The other two, who were agnostics, failed the essay.

Unfortunately, this happens everywhere. It's sad that you're experiencing it at a Catholic school. But hey, what you lack on your transcripts, you'll have in heaven! Way to go for preaching the Truth!
 
Post a Comment



<< Home

This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?